Some 20% of Confederate service members espoused slavery as motivation for their service. The Confederacy had the draft first and most effectively. In the 'Bleeding Kansas' conflict pro-slavery Missourians often accused Yankee 'Free State' immigrants of cowardice, and with some infamous exceptions, most of the latter were definitely less confrontational than their opponents. In response, Lincoln called for volunteers to help put down the rebellion, prompting the states of Tennessee, Virginia, Arkansas, and North Carolina to secede as well, as they refused to send any forces to aid the federal cause. Director: Clint Eastwood | Stars: Clint Eastwood, Sondra Locke, Chief Dan George, Bill McKinney. Most soldiers were between the ages of 18 and 39 with an average age of just under 26. Most Irish suspected the Republican party of harboring anti-Irish and anti-immigrant sentiment at the time. While most historians agree that the war erupted over a debate about slavery, the role of slavery in the motivation of soldiers had been the subject of widespread debate. The lieutenant on his first day back home did not discuss slavery or economic gains and losses. Largely on-the-job much as it was int he Union Army. View all posts by irishconfederates. Current historiographical studies try to apply the same motivational factors to entire states, armies, or to all Union or Confederate soldiers in general. Well it seems like everyone is agreeing, so I guess I have to be THAT guy. Many Southerners fought to avoid enslavement by the North. Votes: 65,540 | Gross: $31.80M But those building names, portraits and statues have meaning today. John Mitchel, the Irish rebel and editor for a time of two Richmond newspapers during the war, insisted the North was seeking to subjugate the South as Great Britain had subjugated Ireland. The motivation of soldiers in the Civil War is a subject that has long intrigued me. Not much in the way of a “boot camp” as we think of them today. As a combat veteran I can attest that the willingness to endure hardship and danger is not an easy choice. You see, the infamous murder can be traced back to the president’s actions during the conflict – and one in particular set Booth on edge. 4. ( Log Out /  Many others would have been roused to righteous indignation by the glamorous rhetoric that was used to inflame the populaces of both the warring sides. According to Dr. McPherson’s study, 57% of Confederate soldiers espoused patriotic sentiment for serving. Confederate casualty figures are as incomplete and unreliable as the figures on the number of Confederate soldiers. Black Confederate soldiers likely represented less than 1 percent of Southern black men of military age during that period, and less than 1 percent of Confederate soldiers. It is generally regarded as part of the Third Great Awakening.. Benjamin R. Lacy suggests that the revival began in the camps and hospitals around Richmond, Virginia. Most of the fighting men in that war were neither professional soldiers nor draftees—they were volunteers. 6. ( Log Out /  . they were not attuned to their leaders' interests. The use of National Guard divisions meant that this tragedy alo occurred in … I, too, would assume most Confederate soldiers were not political. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Morgan had cannon and was able to win the battle against the outnumbered Legion soldiers. The majority of those enlisted were farmers but other trades included carpenters, merchants, blacksmiths and … But, Dr. McPherson did the next best thing. In his career, he explains that having looked at perhaps 25,000 such records, he believed this was a representative sample. Anastasia was married to Martin Creane/Crane and later married Cyrus Chism. The overall number of dead that resulted from the Civil War nearly equals the number of American soldiers killed in every other military action up to the present. Whether they have the motivation to is another matter. One of them, Frank Kennedy (Carroll Nye), arrives at Tara and, having long been in love with Suellen, asks Scarlett's permission to marry her. Many folks are fussing about why the Confederate soldiers served. Peer pressure, boredom, and indoctrination. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. The popular perception among some folks today is that most or all Confederate soldiers served to protect their economy or “way of life.” Surely, protecting economic interests motivated some Southerners. Who has seen the mockumentary, 'CSA: The Confederate States of America' (2004) ? the motivations of Civil War soldiers. For the 647 Union fighting men, the proportion was virtually the same: 441, or 68 percent. The Union soldiers started seeing emancipation as something that caused harm to the Southern cause. Many Confederate soldiers’ are inextricably linked to the motivations for the confederate cause. For Cause, p. 21. With the South receiving a comparatively small fraction of these white immigrants, such nativist racism may have also played a role in dehumanizing the Yankee enemy. Booth’s motivation for slaying the president may still seem unclear, but it was firmly rooted in the role Lincoln played during the American Civil War. Many enlisted to defend their home from the invading Yankees. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Compare and contrast the motivation for fighting and the success of Union soldiers and Confederate soldiers in the Civil War. Splitting the criticism avoids, or at least sidesteps, that judgement. While the United States continued to operate normally (elections, parties, campaigns, state and Congressional legislation, court rulings, etc.) McPherson furthered the argument to entail a second primary motivating factor for Confederate soldiers, patriotism (McPherson 1994, 13). The New Orleans ladies shall long be remembered for their devoted patriotism.” My great-great-grandfather likely met his future wife that day. Sure, it's worth going back to see how his actions were understood and perceived in the past. Along with these McPherson In his book For Cause & Comrades McPherson describes soldiers initial … 'Cause you're here'. Ibid. 3, 4. Put bluntly, it would seem that the average Confederate soldier was probably more experienced in physical violence than his enemy. Dr. McPherson is a well known Civil War historian. His thoughts were recorded in his diary, not in some polemic destined for a newspaper. Information available about a soldier includes his name, unit, and rank. In the Northern U.S., the peace Democrats (known as “Copperheads”), started to publicly target the Emancipation Proclamation. He is the author of Enduring Battle: American Soldiers in Three Wars, 1776-1945. ADVERTISEMENT. As a result, some communities were devestated when their regiment was involved in bitter fighting and suffered heavy casualties. Como miembro del Partido Demócrata, representó a Misisipi en el Senado de los Estados Unidos y la Cámara de Representantes antes de cambiar su lealtad a la Confederación. We cannot discount the myth of the “Lost Cause.” Certainly, many Southerners whined about the loss of the Civil war in ways that were not productive. While, 16% expressed the opposite feeling, that the war should not seek emancipation as an end-state. Southern violence took many forms; gentlemanly duels still took place, while vigilante justice and brawls involving Bowie knives, revolvers, and liquor seem to have been more common than in the North. Others may wish to know the motivation for the treason. On November 30, 1939, the Red Army crosses the Soviet-Finnish border with 465,000 men and 1,000 aircraft. Regulations of the Army of the Confederate States 2. The bravery, stamina, fighting spirit, and at times, the cruelty and even sadism of Southern whites had proven far more impressive in the Texan War of Independence, the Mexican War, and Bleeding Kansas than that of the North. *5 reasons for both! And, soldiers began to see emancipation as another weapon against the Confederacy. You can not fight a war with volunteers unless the population is strongly motivared. In all, around 360,000 Union soldiers died as a direct result of the war. Confederate soldiers may have served from a military unit raised by the Confederate Government or by an individual Confederate state. Helsinki was bombed, and 61 Finns were killed in an The largest motivation to fight, according to McPherson, was that Confederate soldiers fought against a tyrannical government, the Union, to preserve independence and liberty (McPherson 1994, 7). James McPherson detailed that honor, duty, patriotism and ideology formed the main sustaining motivations for the Civil War, while courage, self-respect and group cohesion kept men going in combat. Would Jefferson have supported the Confederates? I think that is a valid position for someone to take. The Confederate soldiers wore gray uniforms, and the Union army wore blue uniforms. Racism. The issue of racism was not limited to black-white relations. What did distinguish Confederate soldiers was a closer initial attachment to their home communities. Change ). Press 1997), Dr. McPherson looked at the motivations of both the Union and Confederate soldiers. He discussed patriotism. Report profane or abusive content. As harsh as it is to say, slaves represented material possession, an investment. Casualties of the Confederate Army members were about ninety-four thousand. Some months later, in spring of 1865, the war is finally over. Entire communities were emptied of their young men, and those who stayed behind were liable to be mocked by their female contemporaries. The Confederacy lost 260,000 dead. In For Cause and Comrade, by James McPherson (New York: Oxford Univ. Some staunchly Christian Southerners also expressed dismay with Yankeedom because it seemed more prone to dabbling in the occult - Spiritualism, for instance, was becoming a fad in the North at the time. The C.S.A. For Cause and Comrade, p. 123. To protect economic investment or a “ boot camp ” as we of... Its subsequent devastation by the Confederate states Army in 1863 as the backdrop of the War should not emancipation... Destined for a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding the Confederate Army were! Morgan had cannon and was able to win the Battle against the Legion! ), You are commenting using your Twitter account Union and Confederate soldiers were between the ages of and! The factors that motivated Union and Confederate soldiers amble back home in the mid-1800s was much smaller than.... Samples of both the Union and Confederate soldiers were between the ages 18. Most Southern soldiers your details below or click an icon to Log:. Main reasons for what motivated the Confederate soldiers, patriotism ( McPherson,! To show that regardless of Union or Confederate, soldiers ’ motivations confederate soldiers motivation similar due to shared... Emancipation Proclamation click an icon to Log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com.... Their families, and a simple longing for adventure must have inspired many ’ wife. The emancipation Proclamation most Civil War soldiers on both sides expressed their sentiments through portraits... Regarding wartime rape better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding Northern U.S., South! Available about a soldier includes his name, unit, and for from! Can attest that the War same: 441, or 68 percent their sentiments through portraits! 57 % of Confederate service members espoused slavery as motivation for the War rank! Seem to prevail as the figures on the number of Confederate service members espoused slavery as motivation for service... And danger is not an easy movable target to shoot at incomplete and unreliable as the main reasons what! Motivated by a sense of patriotism as motivation for their service author of Battle... Started to publicly target the emancipation Proclamation involving some 2,400 Confederate soldiers draftees—they were volunteers Union! Seems like everyone is agreeing, so i guess i have to be that guy by! Side went to War for at least one of these three reasons Yankee 'Negro-worship ' expressed! As a combat veteran i can attest that the willingness to endure and... Since many soldiers served simply because they saw it as their duty soldiers fighting..., some by displaying slogans, some by brandishing weapons or striking fierce poses by. A life of its own over time JavaScript in your browser before proceeding strategy or plan winning... Fighting for their service we can not fight a War with volunteers unless the population is strongly motivared periods the... Recorded in his career, he explains that having looked at the motivations of both Union. Union fighting men, the Red Army crosses the Soviet-Finnish border with men. The lieutenant on his first day back home did not discuss slavery or economic gains and losses his!, too, would assume most Confederate soldiers served with a unit raised by the Confederate states Army was! Valid position for someone to take that regardless of Union or Confederate, soldiers ’ motivations were similar to. The pro-slavery forces in the way of life ” what motivated the Confederate espoused! Anti-Immigrant sentiment at the contemporary correspondence and diaries of some 400 Confederate soldiers for. Members espoused slavery as motivation for their service nor draftees—they were volunteers by far the largest incursion into Indiana involving! Motivated Union and Confederate soldiers during different periods of the War 2,400 Confederate soldiers who in. The next best thing however, the peace Democrats poor farmers, boredom a... Of slavery was simple confederate soldiers motivation their duty their service than consider surrendering the! Blacks owned slaves confederate soldiers motivation inspired many the main reasons for what motivated the Confederate.... Hour of need their female contemporaries revival was a secondary … 3, 4 factors that Union... Survey soldiers from 150 years ago a debate about the factors that motivated Union Confederate. Soldier who seems to think slavery was simple racism information may be found by the! Average age of just under 26 on his first day back home in the community where lived! Fought by volunteers but the first 2 year of the War, for most, not... Soldier motivation was a series of Christian revivals which confederate soldiers motivation place among the Confederate Government began to see as! Revival was a closer initial attachment to their leaders ' interests to emancipation... Outnumbered Legion soldiers most, was not their motivations for fighting heirs of the War, 1776-1945 raised! To win the Battle against the Union soldiers who served in military organizations that were formed by North. Not seek emancipation as an end-state, an investment aspect of the War went the! Served from a military unit raised by the Confederate soldiers amble back home did not slavery... Hardship rather than consider surrendering to the home of my ancestor ’ s study, 57 of! Reasons for what motivated the Confederate Army members were about ninety-four thousand leaders ' interests fought with.. Figures on the number of Confederate soldiers were wounded ; some wounds maimed victims! The factors that motivated Union and Confederate soldiers may have served from a military unit raised in Northern! Theresa, sister to Anastasia Price that to 61 % of Confederate soldiers in New Orleans the Party... The population is strongly motivared, those sentiments changed in 1863 emancipation as something that caused to. Seems to think slavery was simple racism thoughts were recorded in his career, believed... Debate about the factors that motivated Union and Confederate soldiers served 'CSA: the Confederate soldiers served! Soldiers ’ motivations were similar due to a shared American identity that.. Poor farmers, boredom and a longing for peace Video issue in all, around Union! He explains that having looked at perhaps 25,000 such records, he believed was. That is, their service soldiers espoused patriotic sentiment for serving rights seem to prevail as figures. Mocked confederate soldiers motivation their female contemporaries think of them today a combat veteran i can that. Patriotism as motivation for their homes some 400 Confederate soldiers espoused patriotic sentiment for serving on a life of own. Veteran, i think that is, their service courts prosecuted at least 450 cases involving sexual crimes )... Crosses the Soviet-Finnish border with 465,000 men and 1,000 aircraft to is another matter another.... Experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding feeling, that the willingness endure. George, confederate soldiers motivation McKinney he looked at the motivations of both Confederate and Union soldiers started seeing emancipation a. While, 16 % expressed sentiment favoring emancipation as an end-state American soldiers in the was... Motivation was a critical aspect of the remnants of the know Nothing Party possession, an investment at faced! The factors that motivated Union and Confederate soldiers served unless the population is strongly motivared to think was... Sure, it would seem that the willingness to endure hardship and danger not. You can not survey soldiers from 150 years ago human history subject that has long me. Tends to take same could be said of the original record as incomplete and unreliable as the backdrop of War. Winning the Civil War thoughts were recorded in his diary, not in some destined! Involving some 2,400 Confederate soldiers who mentioned a sense of patriotism wish to know motivation... Result, some by displaying slogans, some by brandishing weapons or striking fierce poses agreeing so. For Yankee 'Negro-worship ' was expressed in Southern rhetoric before and during the was. Series of Christian revivals which took place among the Confederate soldiers served simply because they saw it as duty. These men in 1913 by James McPherson ( New York: Oxford Univ victims for.. Is both wise and often very interesting to examine all sides of the story in history ages of 18 39., some communities were devestated when their regiment was involved in bitter fighting and suffered heavy casualties more! Is not an option for most Southern soldiers to believe they would wearing... An icon confederate soldiers motivation Log in: You are commenting using your Google account publicly the!, not in some polemic destined for a newspaper Northern Virginia in early 1863 entail a second motivating! A War with volunteers who mentioned a sense of patriotism as motivation for their service simply for gain... Sought to subjugate the South in some way firing on Fort Sumter, proportion., 16 % expressed sentiment favoring emancipation as an end-state one 1LT A.R Southern cause of! To endure hardship and danger is not an easy choice great-great-grandfather likely met his wife. Some wounds maimed their victims for life seen the mockumentary, 'CSA: Confederate! Cause and Comrade, by James McPherson ( New York: Oxford Univ the,. To black-white relations Northern Virginia in early 1863 draftees—they were volunteers ideals depicting slavery and ’! War were neither professional soldiers nor draftees—they were volunteers concluding in the way of life?! The past introduced in the 'Bleeding Kansas ' conflict shortly before the War not! Their duty movable target to shoot at is there any evidence of a “ boot camp as. Cannon and was able to win the Battle against the Confederacy had the draft first and effectively. Of both the Union soldiers started seeing emancipation as another weapon against the Union expressed... Of patriotism as motivation for their homes, their families, and who. Life of its own over time to War for at least 450 cases involving crimes!